Request for more moderators or to bring back the Arbiters
Forums around the world have always been bad. Deal with it, moderators are spending their time making it a nicer place. Just because stupid posts/threads arn't deleted instantly doesn't mean moderators arn't doing anything.
Last edited by Hikaru on Fri Feb 17, 2006 4:21 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Must've been something really nice. Too bad my all seeing eye was blind at the moment.Vinx wrote:smart move hik.
Anyways.
This community needs alot more active moderators.
I said in another thread, to ditch all moderators.
What I meant was, all inactive moderators. This has already happened( I think ). Just get the experienced and active members, that is, experienced when it comes to holding the peace.
Whatever is done, it is the choice of Grenadiac.
- Iron_Forge
- Posts: 532
- Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2003 9:21 pm
So what your saying is moderators read their PM's, but can't be bothered with reports?.. ;oPKirk wrote:Yes, if you want something really done, PM a mod or admin, reported posts don't always get fixed immediately.
It seems silly to PM a single moderator when you can report something and send the message to all moderators...Then if moderators took the time to actually leave a reason/explanation of what they thought of the report, and actions they took when they closed the report rather than just checking the box, there would be tracking on all reports, offenders, reporters, etc...So you could actually keep track of who's being a constant idiot, rather than only seeing issues here and there because other moderators are dealing with it...
-
- Posts: 1469
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:11 am
- Location: england:lincolnshire
- Contact:
Grenadiac is haxing into my computor..?
Thanks ;oPVinx wrote:smart move hik.
Thanks ;oPInfern0 wrote:Must've been something really nice
you're*Iron_Forge wrote:So what your saying is moderators read their PM's, but can't be bothered with reports?.. ;oP
Iron Forge is actually right about that, if moderators can't be bothered with the report system, we should get Arbiter/Guardians back. I mean, why have the report system if moderators arn't going to use it?
- shadowkhas
- Posts: 5423
- Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2004 8:00 am
- Location: Salt Lake City, Utah
I try to stay on top of reports, I always check them when I'm on. But, as I'm not in the moderator group, I only have three sections that I take care of, and most of the time, reports I see are about signatures. If a report is about the Mac forum, Tags and Resources forum, or Pictures forum, I try to get it done as fast as possible.
(7:15:27 PM) Xenon7: I BRUK THE FIRST PAGE OMGOMGOMG RONALD REGAN
Re: Grenadiac is haxing into my computor..?
Hikaru, I think you're missing the point.Hikaru wrote:Iron Forge is actually right about that, if moderators can't be bothered with the report system, we should get Arbiter/Guardians back. I mean, why have the report system if moderators arn't going to use it?
Quality > Quantity
TF6
Re: Grenadiac is haxing into my computor..?
That is why i should be admin.Aequitas wrote:Hikaru, I think you're missing the point.Hikaru wrote:Iron Forge is actually right about that, if moderators can't be bothered with the report system, we should get Arbiter/Guardians back. I mean, why have the report system if moderators arn't going to use it?
Quality > Quantity
Logan is dead.
- Iron_Forge
- Posts: 532
- Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2003 9:21 pm
I disagree...People have emblems to work towards...There is an emblem that basically says "I'm a guardian type person", and has the added bonus of other emblems...Something a simple name change can't do...So not only do you know people are helpful, you know they're helpful skinners, or helpful modders, or helpful "something"...I've seen lots of guardians spewing things out of their <insert location of spewing> that they have no concept of, and are just giving out false information under the guise of knowing...Which is worse in my opinion than just not helping in the first place...jks wrote:I think getting arbiter system back would be fun, I really think it helped the users to have something to look forward to and something to work towards, plus guardians encourage helping people. Sometimes you have to dangle a carrot in front of a horse to get it moving :wink:
There are enough people with emblems now you can figure out what the majority of them are...Least, I have...Maybe I could put together a list of what I believe the major ones are, so people could go back to "working towards something"...
All that being said, if users are only doing things to get something in return, isn't that the kind of "mod for fame" people everyone hates these days?..I'd hate to have people helping just so they can get something out of it, rather than helping to help...
I think this was a huge issue with the old arbiter/guardian, and even moderator ranks...People only did things to get these ranks...And once they had them, they stopped doing anything, or only continued doing things so they could claim "well, so and so was promoted, I'm better than them, I deserve a promotion now" or "so and so was promoted from mod to JA, so now they're incapable of doing moderator things, I should be promoted from arbiter to mod"...
In my opinion, moderation is a job, not a hobby...You shouldn't accept the position lightly, and once accepted, you should actually make an effort to do it, not "clean things as you happen to read them in posts that look of interest to you"...As Aequitas said, Quality over Quantity...Moderators need to step up and actually look for issues rather than sitting back and waiting for problems to come to them...The report system was implimented to make this easier for them...Not to be ignored as just another post they don't want to read...
-
- Posts: 1469
- Joined: Wed Feb 23, 2005 4:11 am
- Location: england:lincolnshire
- Contact:
Re: Grenadiac is haxing into my computor..?
u could make malf and veegie a admin or mod as well im sure it would have some sort of effect on the site.Xero wrote: That is why i should be admin.
-
- Posts: 293
- Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:51 pm
Re: Grenadiac is haxing into my computor..?
No and No. The forums would have serious problems if they did that.=sw=warlord wrote: u could make malf and veegie a admin or mod as well im sure it would have some sort of effect on the site.
- INSANEdrive
- Posts: 2642
- Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2004 1:42 pm
- Location: Cell Block #Q (There are a lot of strange people in the world. I should know; I'm three of them...)
- Contact:
Aaa yes.. The All Knowing Mysterious Emblems...Iron_Forge wrote:I disagree...People have emblems to work towards...There is an emblem that basically says "I'm a guardian type person", and has the added bonus of other emblems...Something a simple name change can't do...So not only do you know people are helpful, you know they're helpful skinners, or helpful modders, or helpful "something"...I've seen lots of guardians spewing things out of their <insert location of spewing> that they have no concept of, and are just giving out false information under the guise of knowing...Which is worse in my opinion than just not helping in the first place...jks wrote:I think getting arbiter system back would be fun, I really think it helped the users to have something to look forward to and something to work towards, plus guardians encourage helping people. Sometimes you have to dangle a carrot in front of a horse to get it moving
There are enough people with emblems now you can figure out what the majority of them are...Least, I have...Maybe I could put together a list of what I believe the major ones are, so people could go back to "working towards something"...
All that being said, if users are only doing things to get something in return, isn't that the kind of "mod for fame" people everyone hates these days?..I'd hate to have people helping just so they can get something out of it, rather than helping to help...
Not to Change the subject... But.. It Would Help what to work towards for an album
Also Which one... How Do I Know Which one Says such
I have also at times seen people pretty new to forums and modding with elbems...not proving anything ( to my knowledge at least)... but meh... the least you could say is which one means Leet skinner;)
..Now then Back on t3h subject at hand...
I think this was a huge issue with the old arbiter/guardian, and even moderator ranks...People only did things to get these ranks...And once they had them, they stopped doing anything, or only continued doing things so they could claim "well, so and so was promoted, I'm better than them, I deserve a promotion now" or "so and so was promoted from mod to JA, so now they're incapable of doing moderator things, I should be promoted from arbiter to mod"...
In my opinion, moderation is a job, not a hobby...You shouldn't accept the position lightly, and once accepted, you should actually make an effort to do it, not "clean things as you happen to read them in posts that look of interest to you"...As Aequitas said, Quality over Quantity...Moderators need to step up and actually look for issues rather than sitting back and waiting for problems to come to them...The report system was implimented to make this easier for them...Not to be ignored as just another post they don't want to read...
Agree 99% (Im not Sure what the one% is... But I
"You know what I'd like to be? I mean if I had my goddamn choice, I'd just be the catcher in the rye and all."
or should I?