Modding on XBL for machinima?

[Kewlkyle64]

I was playing a game of SWAT on XBL with a couple of my friends. One of them mentioned how in a clan he used to be in, one of the guys modded a map and played Xbox Live with it so it could help a machinima movie their clan was making. The other guy said "You can't do that, that's cheating!" And they got into this huge argument. But it made me curious- is modding on XBL for the sole purpose of machinima a bad thing?

It's a hard decision. Considering that it's not neccessarily cheating, it's still modding on XBL, which I know everyone on Halomods hates. But then again, for making a movie?

In my opinion, I don't think mods should be put on XBL, machinima or not, for any reason. But what are your thoughts? I'd love to hear them.

[JK-47]

Modified content on XBL for any reason is not allowed. It's irrelevant whether the purposes for it are innocent and productive; It's just not allowed.

[GametagAeonFlux]

I don't think mods should be put on XBL, machinima or not, for any reason.

That's pretty much it.

[V0Lt4Ge]

No, modding on XBL for machinima is stupid, especially since they could just do it over XBC or Kai.

[Tural]

There is no excuse for using modified content on Live. There are other alternatives that work fine, as Voltage said.