Here are my thoughts on the logos. Not trying to be mean or anything, just some criticisms.
Trulife8342 wrote:

Not subtle or professional enough; plus it uses the hand-drawn raster logo they are trying to get away from.
shadowkhas wrote:
Not bad but a little too turquoise, and its smaller than it should be.
-Legendary- wrote:
Good, but not great.
RaVNzCRoFT wrote:
I like it a lot, especially as a stand-alone image, but the black is awfully strong with the rest of the site.
diamondbackk60 wrote:

Uhhh...where to begin? It's almost impossible to read, the font and colors don't go with the rest of the site, and the shadow is too much.
CabooseJr wrote:
Cool looking, but way too busy for a logo.
MarsMartianMan wrote:
Scanlines don't scale well and the blue is a little to dark for the background color, but not bad.
Cuda wrote:
Basically just the regular outline font with a drop shadow. Would be fine if it weren't so aliased.
HPDarkness1 wrote:
It's ok but I prefer the original HaloMods font.
noscottno wrote:

Alias issues and the yellow doesnt work.