The thing is, is that Halo 2 vista uses higher resolution textures doesn't it? While I agree gamespots comparison was horrible (if the game looked that dull, blurred and pixellated I'd never have bought it), but by you resizing the image, it kinda gets rid of the extra high definition detail that was added...
However, I don't really know too much as I don't have h2v.
Still a better comparison
